Tuesday, 4 November 2025

Gig Review: Holly Carter - Temperance, Leamington Spa. Sunday 2nd November 2025



Looking forward to a Holly Carter gig simmers with anticipation; basking in the aftermath accrues the satisfaction of spending time in the musical company of a wonderful artist. Instrumental prowess is the most celebrated side of her armoury, yet when combined with a sublime voice, acute song writing and engrossing presentation skills, the ingredients for a special night are in place. Leamington Spa was the latest stop on a run of dates promoting the recently released full length debut album. With Joe Wilkins on guitar and John Parker on double bass, the stage was set for a show that eventually stretched a lot further than a take on a very good record.

The Temperance is a live music gift to the town of Leamington Spa. Additionally, its accessible location draws people from neighbouring urban areas like Leicester, Coventry and the West Midlands. A first descent into the basement performing space is an eye opener. Repeated ones still hone in on a unique charm. The packed schedule is a testimony to an organiser’s commitment to grassroots music, especially those leaning towards folk, country and blues. Holly Carter fitted the bill perfectly and left a gilded imprint after a delightful performance.

The evening was split into two parts. Joe Wilkins warmed up the audience with three guitar instrumentals including one of a classical origin. Whether sampling solo or playing with a number of artists including Elles Bailey, he is one of the leading guitarists on the scene. His presence on Holly Carter’s songs, both acoustic and electric, was notable. The main set ran almost to the hour and half mark which far exceeds the length of recorded material available. Then again, a few covers and bouts of informative chat extended the experience to a hugely enjoyable evening.

In her own words, song influences fall into two camps: social justice especially through the union movement and mental health. The one middle ground part was a personally inspired love song titled ‘Waiting For You To Come Home’. As expected the entirety of Leave Your Mark was played, starting with the informative story song ‘Stetson Kennedy’ and ending, like the album, with the instrumental ‘Morewen’. There was however one added and unexpected treat in a Mozart-inspired bluegrass piece with Carter and Wilkins in full flow and wholly in tandem. 

The song writing side to Holly Carter is shaping up to be a real gem. ‘What You See’, ‘Follow Your Lead’ and ‘Bear With Me’ are songs with genuine quality and weave smart lyrics with memorable melodies. The latter was one of two songs played on the pedal steel guitar, a trademark part of her musicianship leading to accolades like AMA UK Instrumentalist of the Year. The other song getting the extra twang treatment was ‘Moody River’, first brought to her attention via a version from Doc Watson.

Holly Carter subtly slides in a political leaning through a desire to keep the flame of past heroes burning. American unionist/songwriter Joe Hill is an iconic figure celebrated by many musicians from Otis Gibbs to Billy Bragg. Carter has produced an in-depth presentation of his life and legacy, taking it to places like the Maverick Festival in the summer. One musical outcome has been a fabulous version of ‘Where the Fraser River Flows’ where she totally puts her stamp on an uplifting anthem. On the topic of musical heroes with a cause, the other cover played was ‘Bob Dylan’s ‘Song to Woody’, two legends inspiring Holly Carter in addition to The Clash, Manic Street Preachers, John Fogerty and numerous others. 

Stories flowed throughout as the focus also veered to songs off a 2021 EP in ‘Stella’ and ‘Our Hands Are Tied’. There was even a moment where the guitar was put down allowing the gorgeous vocals the space to sparkle to new levels. Throughout, the picking of Carter and Wilkins was exemplary, not forgetting the added dimension of John Parker’s stand-up bass. He is such an experienced operator that borrowing his skills will enhance any performance. 

Holly Carter and the Temperance were a good fit on this Sunday evening. She continues to evolve as a treasured talent, while the venue retains its critical presence in the ecosystem of live independent music.