
Without dismissing the concept of the sum of the whole being
better than the parts, the lasting impression of a Hot Club gig is the
incredible musicianship frequently displayed on a solo platform. Jake Erwin
gave the most high-energised performance on upright bass seen for a long time,
played with impeccable timing and tuneful rigour. Elana James took the fiddle
to places rarely seen in a non-virtuoso setting and peaked with an
extraordinary pre-encore instrumental finale raising the stakes of the evening
to crescendo proportions. Whether Whit Smith was playing his trademark 1928
Gibson L-5 or not, the sound from his guitar of choice oozed with classic twang
and picking that probably tripled the old adage of ‘three chords’, whether in
rhythm or solo.

The vocals are slightly tilted towards Elana who co-founded
the band with Whit in New York City back in the 1990’s. Whit also contributes
solo vocal pieces such as on ‘My Window
Faces South’ and is obviously an integral part of the three part harmonies
when Jake breaks off from his frantic bass slapping to participate. All three
brought the evening to an exciting close with a dual encore combination of the
fantastic and poignant ‘Reunion’
followed by the ever fetching ‘Get Along
Home Cindy’.
There may be solo projects by Elana and Whit in motion but
surely on the evidence of this evening’s performance the three piece band can continue
to entertain and excite audiences around the world. Whether satisfying their
own passion for the European jazz sound or flying the traditional flag for the
core country music sub-genre of western swing, Hot Club of Cowtown remain important,
influential and highly credible players on today’s music scene.